There appears a lot of enthusiasm for building a battery energy storage system, called BESS by the wonks who don't have time for whole words, near the county emergency operations center off Paradies Lane. There's a subset of residents who are extremely engaged in local municipal affairs in one way or another, including advocating for development that reflects their values, which in this case means encouraging the battery storage that's needed to use variable renewable energy when it's needed, not when it's generated. That project's developers say that the environmental review needs to be complete by next September to guarantee funding, but not everyone is convinced this will be possible. That's because town council members have not given their blessing to exempting this project from local zoning and review, in favor of letting county planners supervising and approving the work, which will be performed through Albany company Key Capture Energy, LLC on county property.
Following what's called the Monroe balancing test, town officials could avoid the potential bloat of dueling bureaucracies by determining that it's in the public interest to allow the approvals to run through the other layer of government. This test was used for building the emergency services center, and for expanding the veterans' cemetery. This time, though, there are headwinds. Council member Sean O'Sullivan expressed a reluctance to yield control several times during the Nov. 18 joint meeting. More significantly, town planning board members asked for it to be their project to review.
A number of people spoke in support of completing the nine-part test and finding that it's in the public interest to exempt the project, which would place the burden instead on those in the county planning department, headed by Dennis Doyle. Leonard Loza wondered if electricity savings would benefit New York City users, or would be felt locally. Joe Londa laid out a rationale for granting this request to make the county the lead agency, noting that the brownfield status of the site limits the types of uses, and adding that the fire code, which is central to the safety of this facility, can be applied easily by county professionals and their hired consultants.
| Joe Londa testifies before the joint boards about battery storage |
Several of those speaking repeated very specific ideas, such as that the electricity grid doesn't have a lot of time and needs projects like this to shore it up. Those speaking also included populations that don't tend to show up in force without a lot of encouragement, in this case college students and people from out of town.
Speaking for fellow planning board members, Matt DiDonna asked for the project not to be declared exempt, and even to hold off performing the Monroe test until after the environmental review. "There are many benefits [to a battery facility], but it is a new technology." To ensure proper mitigation, "the location needs to be reviewed locally." There are wetlands on the site, which have been a focal point for a variety of proposed site uses over the decades, and it's only a few hundred feet from residences. Pointedly, DiDonna expressed being "not comfortable with how the county is handling the project." This was a request to have this review done "by those who know the town best."
This was enough to get council members' attention. Supervisor Tim Rogers said that "we want them to feel empowered," making this a "difficult situation." Shutting planning board members out could demoralize some, and Rogers noted that there are already vacancies that need filling.
Getting into the weeds is where it can be hard to justify agreeing to their request, though. There's no application before the planning board, which means the planning board can't serve as the lead agency. Even if an application were made, there's nothing in the zoning code about battery energy storage systems.
According to Doyle, there are three ways to address that lack of zoning: amend the code, determine that this project qualifies as a "public utility" and issue a permit on that basis, or use the balancing test and hand the review over to county officials. Doyle also offered to create an advisory committee that would include members of New Paltz's town council and planning board to provide input.
To O'Sullivan, an advisory committee falls short because they wouldn't be able to vote. Doyle countered that groups like these tend to work on consensus most of the time, with votes being taken infrequently. Amending zoning would require a public hearing and comment from county planning board members. In theory, that work could be undertaken while simultaneously pursuing local site-plan review. Doyle believes none of the local options would be faster than a county-level process.
DiDonna brushed back some skepticism from council member Kitty Brown that these volunteers would be up to the task that could be handled by paid county staffers, saying, "This is a big deal," and that this request would not be made if they weren't ready to put in the work.
Still, without the zoning there is no permit to be issued, and that's the goal of any developer. Another way to change that is to get a determination that this project fits the code definition for a public utility. A prior building inspector, Stacy Delarede, declined to make that determination until it's hooked into the power grid. Lyle Nolan, the current director of that department, has signaled no interest in making that decision.
Others have suggested securing a variance, but Dolan rejected that as unlikely to succeed. This would require a use variance, and the planning director doesn't believe it would meet the stringent requirements to issue one.
It was agreed that revisiting deeming this a public utility was worth the time. Nolan will be provided with case law to support an argument for making the determination, and DiDonna will get comment from the planning board's attorney about different options for keeping it local. The fun continues Dec. 3.
Want to make a comment? Send in a letter for possible future publication. Want to support local, independent journalism? Buy me a coffee.
