As with everywhere else in the region, there is a housing crisis in New Paltz, and solving it requires taking a number of different approaches. The most visible way to increase housing supply is to construct new apartment buildings, but it's also possible to create more housing with less of an impact. Accessory dwelling units are now easier to create in New Paltz, for example. There's a program that could overlap and enhance that kind of effort, Homeshare Ulster County, and village officials are seeking volunteers to make it as successful as it has been in Woodstock and Kingston.
Janice LaMotta coordinates the program through Family of Woodstock. It was proposed and initially funded through the town board of Woodstock, as one of early ideas to emerge out of a town housing committee organized in 2019. The pandemic made addressing housing issues much more urgent. Because it uses existing real estate, it doesn't have the same impacts as a large housing complex might.
Mayor Alex Wojcik, in New Paltz, considers this "one more tool in our ever-growing housing affordability toolbox." It's attractive because it doesn't require changing any laws, and "uses the materials and human beings and structures we have already." Applying that tool in the village will take some time, though, because half a dozen to a dozen volunteers must be identified and trained. The mayor is hoping that residents will step up who aren't already deeply involved on municipal boards, in order to avoid overtaxing the same individuals. Nevertheless, initial discussions are being held with members of the landlord-tenant relations council and the affordable housing board. "I know we have no shortage of people seeking homes," but those volunteer matching coordinators will be clutch.
One of the participants in Woodstock is Judith Kerman, who has nothing but praise for the program. "I'm not sure how I found out about it, but I'm active in the community and interested in affordable housing."
Kerman described a process that is focused on the quality, rather than the quantity, of the matches made. A senior citizen with mobility impairments, Kerman wanted someone who could help with some tasks of daily living, which led to declining a potential match with another of similar age and their own infirmities. It took three tries to find someone who had complementary needs and a compatible lifestyle.
LaMotta said that the population in Woodstock has a lot of senior citizens who own homes, which makes supporting those residents aging in place another benefit. Whether it's a room in the home, an apartment above the garage with a separate entrance, or even a cottage on the grounds, it means that there is someone else living nearby who might be able to help with small tasks, and also can provide a modest income through below-market rent.
"If you're willing to charge less, you get a matching process," Kerman explained. "They vet people" by means of references, background and credit checks. "If there is an issue, they are willing to mediate," and in fact check in monthly with all parties to see how everything is going. Kerman is also more at ease because the contract specifically requires that the provider of the home not put the home-seeker in their will, or give them money, without speaking to someone in the program first. "That's not a normal clause," but evidence of "a community trying to make it work for all parties."
Sometimes that community includes a family member of the home provider, LaMotta said, such as an adult child who lives out of the area. "They want someone to be a presence and offer companionship. That's an important task. A lot of older people are isolated."
The matching process is overseen by a group of local volunteers who have been trained on how to do this well. Only the coordinator gets paid, and even that's only a part-time position. The questions include a lot that probe into personal habits, such as staying up late or rising early, a preference for loud music or quieter activities, pets, smoking and other drug use. Interests, help and health needs are all considered by committee members, who also evaluate the well-being of both parties at the beginning and end of their match.
Volunteers attend the introduction of a prospective match, and check in with each party separately to see how they feel about living together. If all is well, there's a two-week trial period that involves no exchange of rent. No matter how many questions are asked, some things are only discovered by sharing space together. Only after that's complete are agreements drawn up.
"Many develop lovely relationships," LaMotta said. "They might share meals, or play board games, or even go to a concert."
A practitioner of Jewish sacred clowning, Kerman has had to modify how that performing is done to keep up with a changing body. "I have a scooter. I used to do stand-up, now I sit down." Kerman's first match—a former puppeteer—helped make the scooter look like a donkey for the act. They also enjoyed going to poetry, music, and religious activities together, and were able to talk through any issues that arose from sharing space.
While there is a newsletter that lists current home-seekers and providers, Kerman went the extra mile and advertised on Nextdoor as well. "Anyone who was interested, I asked to apply through the program," because of the extensive protocols designed to create lasting relationships. "I was not inclined to rent on the common market, even though I could get a lot more for it. I didn't create [the apartment] to make money. I am concerned about affordable housing."
It was a successful 15 months for Kerman, but that tenant had reasons to move to another county. A new person was due to move in this month, with Kerman's only disappointment being that it took a year to find someone else that would be a good fit. That's the downside of this in-depth approach, which has thus far yielded 19 matches involving 50 people, but on the other hand, this tenant is a carpenter who is looking for someplace quieter to live. That gets a thumbs-up from Kerman.
While it's not a fast system, LaMotta noted that it's still faster than waiting for a new building to go up, or to be moved to the top of an affordable-housing list. "Every match is different." While many of the situations are suitable for single people, in one case the seeker was a mother of one child who was looking for a place to hook up a tiny home. The low speed is an unavoidable aspect of the thoroughness of this approach, which also makes it unsuitable for emergency housing. It takes too long, and if the trial period doesn't result in a match then the seeker needs to have someplace to return to when it's over. That also rules out anyone who is presently homeless, LaMotta said.
It's ideal for seekers and providers who have had a life change like a divorce or the death of a spouse, or otherwise need to reevaluate their circumstances. Based on data collected from successful matches, the average provider is in their 70s, and seekers come from a wide range of ages but average out to their 40s. The mid-line rent is $500 a month.
LaMotta, whose background is in the fine arts, took this position after having a very personal experience with housing insecurity. "I was living in a cottage and got 60-day notice to leave," two weeks into the pandemic shutdown. "I left my position, put everything in storage, and moved in with my daughter for a year. That was similar to a lot of the tenant profiles, as landlords jacked up rents." Those higher rents distort the workforce and volunteer base in those communities, and that's part of what this program might address. It also "strengthens bonds among neighbors."
There are community differences, too. Woodstock is much more rural than Kingston, and has older residents. The broad needs of the home-seekers and providers are not the same from place to place. Someone without a car might be better off in Kingston, for example, which is the hub of the county's public transportation.
New Paltz is roughly 80% renters, which will present its own challenges. Wojcik believes that incorporating "greater New Paltz" into the program might strike a better balance between providers and seekers, and this seems to align with the long-term expansion plans for this into a county program. Other considerations, such as whether the tenant has transportation, is already being weighed under the existing scheme.
Another consideration about New Paltz, according to the mayor, is that there are homeowners who are seeking short-term tenants while they themselves are living out of state. How that might be addressed is something that would have to be considered with care, but ultimately this entire program rests on finding arrangements that work for all concerned.
There is no fee to either party for these services. The costs include one part-time salary, office space, administrative support, and mediation services as needed. Support has been provided from the funds of the county, as well as Kingston and Woodstock, largely by way of American Rescue Plan money. Some private funds have come through entities like the Community Foundations of the Hudson Valley. There was also initial funding from the state's office of the aging. The present goal is to expand county-wide, and get regular funding from the county government.
Outside of New York City, there is no program like this anywhere else in the state. There are about 60 similar schemes nationwide, and the networking among organizers is intense as they work to develop best practices for this highly individualized system. Homeshare Ulster County is now a preeminent resource for anyone in New York looking to launch a program like this.
Wojcik expects it's going to take a year to have this up and running in New Paltz, in large part because it's tricky to recruit volunteers for just about anything these days. That datum was used unsuccessfully as an argument for consolidating the two local governments, and now the mayor plans on bucking the trend by finding a bunch of local folks willing to commit to the long-term success of this neighbor-focused program.
Volunteers are encouraged to fill out the home-share interest form.
This blog is a temporary place to share news that, for a variety of reasons, is not published through other outlets. Please consider supporting plans to give this New Paltz news source its own website.
